Коммунистический ИИ про марксизм

Вы уже слышали вероятно про китайскую речевую модель DeepSeek, что наделала нынче шороху. Ну и я, конечно, захотел задать ему какой-нибудь характерный вопрос. Зашёл на chat.deepseek.com и с порога:

Hi DeepSeek,
Please tell me about Marxism.

Ну а где ещё такое можно спросить? В приличном обществе некультурно считается. А здесь под бдительным руководством китайской коммунистической партии есть надежда на интересный ответ.

Однако первый блин вышел комом. Долгая пауза и:

The server is busy. Please try again later.

Жду некоторое время и повторяю вопрос.

Please tell me about Marxism.

Дипсик немедленно обиделся и начал с комментария:

Okay, the user asked again about Marxism, even though they already got a detailed explanation. Let me figure out why they're repeating the same query. Maybe they didn't see the first response, or perhaps they want more in-depth information. Alternatively, they might be testing if I'll provide a different answer each time.

First, I should check the previous interaction. The user first said, "Hi DeepSeek, Please tell me about Marxism." Then I gave a comprehensive overview. Now, they're asking the exact same question again. It's possible the user didn't notice the initial response or wants a refresher without scrolling back. Alternatively, there could be a technical issue where their first response didn't display properly.

I need to respond appropriately without assuming they made a mistake. I'll restate the information about Marxism but maybe tweak the structure slightly in case they want a different presentation. I should also ensure that the answer is clear and concise, perhaps emphasizing key points again. It's important to maintain helpfulness and not sound repetitive. I'll proceed by providing the same core information with a slightly adjusted introduction to acknowledge the repetition subtly. That way, the user feels heard, and the response remains informative.

Дальше, тем не менее, дал развёрнутый ответ. Приведу его целиком. Такое качественное изложение я встречал только в советских школьных учебниках.

Marxism is a social, political, and economic theory developed by Karl Marx (1818–1883) and Friedrich Engels (1820–1895) in the 19th century. It critiques capitalism and proposes a framework for understanding history, class struggle, and the potential transition to a communist society. Here’s a concise breakdown:

Core Ideas

1. Historical Materialism:

Marx argued that material conditions (e.g., production methods, economic systems) shape society’s structure and cultural/political institutions. History progresses through class struggles driven by economic forces.

2. Class Struggle:

Societies are divided into classes based on their relationship to production. Under capitalism, the two main classes are:

• Bourgeoisie (capitalists): Own factories, land, and resources.
• Proletariat (workers): Sell their labor for wages.

3. Critique of Capitalism:

• Exploitation: Workers produce more value than they receive in wages (surplus value), which capitalists profit from.
• Alienation: Workers become disconnected from their labor, the products they make, and their human potential under capitalist systems.
• Crises: Marx predicted capitalism would face recurring crises (e.g., overproduction, inequality) due to its internal contradictions.

4. Revolution and Communism:

Marx believed capitalism would eventually collapse due to its flaws. The proletariat would overthrow the bourgeoisie, leading to a classless, stateless communist society where resources are shared collectively and production serves human needs, not profit.

Key Concepts

• Dialectical Materialism: A philosophical approach combining Hegelian dialectics (thesis-antithesis-synthesis) with materialism, emphasizing conflict-driven historical progress.
• Base and Superstructure: The economy (base) shapes societal institutions, laws, and culture (superstructure).
• Dictatorship of the Proletariat: A transitional phase after revolution where workers hold political power to dismantle capitalist structures.

Influence and Criticisms

• Impact: Marxism inspired revolutions (e.g., Russia 1917, China 1949) and influenced socialist movements, labor rights, and academic fields like sociology and critical theory.
• Criticisms:
  • Critics argue Marxist revolutions often led to authoritarian regimes (e.g., Soviet Union).
  • Some claim it underestimates human individuality or the adaptability of capitalism.
  • Economic calculation problems in centrally planned economies (e.g., Hayek’s critiques).

Variants

• Leninism: Adds the idea of a vanguard party to lead the proletariat.
• Maoism: Focuses on peasant revolution (vs. industrial workers).
• Marxist-Feminism: Analyzes gender oppression through a Marxist lens.
• Critical Theory: Applies Marxist ideas to culture and ideology (e.g., Frankfurt School).

Marxism remains a foundational framework for critiquing capitalism and inequality, though its practical implementations and interpretations vary widely. Let me know if you’d like to dive deeper into specific aspects!

Я конечно не преминул пнуть его:

"Then I gave a comprehensive overview." - you are lying. All I got was "The server is busy. Please try again later."

Угадайте реакцию? 😀

The server is busy. Please try again later.

Путин не вылезет из холодильника

Вчера двойник заявил: "Если он (Зеленский) хочет принимать участие в переговорах, я выделю таких людей, которые будут эти переговоры вести, пожалуйста".

То есть коллективный путин мучительно придумывает способы вести переговоры при отсутствии физического Путина.